A legal confrontation has erupted between FBI Director Kash Patel and The Atlantic reporter Sarah Fitzpatrick after a report was published that alleged Patel engaged in excessive drinking on Friday. Patel’s legal team is now threatening court action and has released a letter sent prior to publication disputing the claims.
The letter, authored by Patel’s attorney Jesse Binnall and dated April 17, 2026, accuses the magazine of preparing to publish “categorically false and defamatory assertions” about the FBI chief. It further claims the publication was warned in advance but proceeded regardless.
“This is the letter we sent… BEFORE they published their hit piece,” Binnall wrote on X, adding, “They were on notice… They published anyway. See you in court.”
Read more: Kash Patel mocks Eric Swalwell amid rape allegations, ‘Door is open to all’
Legal letter outlines sweeping denial of allegations
According to the letter, Binnall’s firm warned The Atlantic that its draft article contained at least 19 claims, “most of which are false, unsourced, and facially defamatory.”
The document specifically refutes several allegations, including claims that Patel drank “to the point of apparent intoxication,” was difficult to reach during critical moments, and required security intervention after becoming unresponsive behind locked doors. It also disputes assertions that his conduct posed a threat to public safety or delayed key counterterrorism decisions.
The letter further states that officials from the FBI’s Office of Public Affairs had already dismissed the claims as “completely false at a nearly 100% clip.”
Binnall’s communication also accuses the magazine of relying on vague, unattributed sources such as “people familiar with the matter,” arguing that such sourcing lacks credibility and fails to meet journalistic standards.
Read more: After DOW leaker’s arrest, Kash Patel says ‘got more coming’ in brutal warning
What does the report allege?
The dispute follows a detailed report by The Atlantic written by Fitzpatrick, which cited multiple unnamed officials alleging Patel engaged in excessive drinking, erratic behavior and unexplained absences.
The Atlantic’s report, based on interviews with current and former officials, paints a starkly different picture. It lists serious allegations that Patel’s behaviour raised serious concerns within national security circles.
Among the claims are that his alleged drinking habits affected his availability for briefings and that his conduct could pose risks during emergencies. The report also suggests internal unease within the FBI and Department of Justice about leadership stability.
The report alleges that Patel is “known to drink to the point of obvious intoxication, in many cases at the private club Ned’s in Washington, D.C., while in the presence of White House and other administration staff. He is also known to drink to excess at the Poodle Room, in Las Vegas.”
Binnall’s letter, however, labeled both these allegations as false and defamatory.